Mid-Term Shopping Trucking Insurance? Here’s How It Can Cost You more
.png)
You’re six months into your policy. Rates feel too high. Your agent’s gone quiet. Someone online says they’re paying less.
We get it. Insurance is one of your top three costs, and the urge to lower those costs is real. You’re not wrong for looking. You just need to know what you’re walking into.
And as for your agent? Unless they totally suck at service, chances are they’re just out of options. This year has been rough on all of us. Prices are up across the board. Markets are tightening. And if they haven’t come to you with some magical rate drop, it’s probably because there isn’t one.
But mid-term shopping your trucking insurance anyway? That’s where things start to backfire.
Let’s break down why most carriers won’t touch it and why quoting now might hurt more than help.
First Off:
You're allowed to shop and change carriers anytime. No one’s locking you into a contract you can’t break.
But just because you can doesn’t mean you should. Unless there’s a serious issue, mid-term shopping is rarely the best use of your time. It also sends the wrong signals to the market.
Most Carriers Won’t Quote Mid-Term. Here’s Why.
Underwriters see mid-term quoting as a red flag. The bind ratio is terrible. Most of these quotes don’t bind, so they don’t want to waste time on a risk that’s already placed.
And it’s not because they think you’re bluffing. It’s because they do this every single day. They’ve seen it all.
Rates are trending up fast. We’ve seen increases of 5 to 30 percent in just the last few months. So when someone comes mid-policy asking for a better deal, there usually isn’t one. What’s out there now is the same stuff you passed on at renewal, just more expensive.
Carriers like Progressive, GEICO, and BHHC might quote you mid-term. But if they weren’t a good fit a few months ago, they still aren’t now. They’re just the last ones left willing to look.
It Makes You Look Risky
Carriers talk. Underwriters remember. If you get a reputation for quote-hopping mid-policy, it sticks. Even with a clean record, quoting mid-term raises questions. Did something go wrong? Are you hiding a claim? Are you going to shop again in six months?
That kind of volatility makes you look less stable and less insurable.
New Quote? New Rules.
That quote you got back in April is dead. Every new submission requires fresh loss runs. Carriers won’t work off the old ones. And yes, they’re also pulling your CBIS score again.
If you’ve financed a truck, taken on a loan, bought a home, or co-signed on college tuition, your credit profile may have changed. That can make your new quote worse than the one you already have.
You’re Still On the Hook
Some carriers have minimum earned premiums, often 25% of the full policy. That means they keep 25% whether you cancel after two months or ten.
Always check if your cancellation is pro-rated or not before you make a move.
When It Does Make Sense to Switch
We’re not saying never. We’re saying be smart.
If you were misclassified, can’t get COIs, your agent went dark, or a unit change blew up your rate, we’ll take a look. And if your carrier is pulling out of the market altogether, it’s time to move.
But quoting just because you’re annoyed with the price is not a strategy. It’s a setup for more problems.
What You Should Be Doing Instead
What will? Getting proactive about renewal, starting now.
Keep your loss history clean. Every claim counts. The fewer payouts on your file, the more leverage we have to negotiate at renewal.
Push for clean inspections. Every time you get stopped, it’s a chance to build a better report card. Good inspections help tell a safety story that underwriters actually believe.
Cut the driver churn. Constant turnover looks risky. Keep your roster steady and train the team you have.
Track everything. Keep your IFTA filings clean, report mileage accurately, and fix your equipment issues before they turn into violations.
Tell a strong story. Underwriters aren’t just looking at numbers. They’re looking at patterns. If your paperwork, safety record, and renewal app all line up, you’ve got a shot at competitive pricing.
This is how you get ahead. Not by chasing quotes when the market is already hardened, but by giving us real ammo to go to bat for you when the timing is right.
Trust Goes Both Ways
When you find a good agent, we hope you trust them. Not just to get you a decent price, but to match you with the right carrier for how you actually operate.
That means trusting us to shop at renewal when it makes sense. And just as important, trusting us not to shop mid-policy when it doesn’t.
Agents can’t control the market. We can’t force carriers to rewrite a risk just because your buddy down the street got a quote off Facebook. But we can do our job if you let us.
We’ve seen truckers expect the world from their agent, only to jump ship because some personal lines rep at a car insurance office says their Progressive rate is fifteen bucks cheaper a month.
You hired a trucking specialist for a reason.
Let’s not waste time chasing what doesn’t serve you.
Our Take
We’re not anti-shopping. We’re anti-wasting your time on quotes from the same carriers you already passed on.
If your policy is working, ride it out. Use the time to prep for renewal with clean loss runs, updated IFTAs, and solid paperwork.
But if your coverage is actually broken, let’s fix it the right way.
Need a Second Opinion?
We don’t shop you mid-term unless there’s a real reason. But if something’s gone sideways, we’ll tell you straight.
Email us: info@trucku.biz
